Faculty and Staff Directory
Administration
Kathleen Kilty
President
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because of the wonderful people I have the privilege of interacting with each day and because it gives me the opportunity to live my faith each day in meaningful ways.
Alexis Burns
Assistant Principal, Director, Seton-LaCroce Learning Center
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because it has always felt like home. As a student here, I experienced firsthand the caring community that makes this school so special, and now I have the privilege of giving back as an educator and parent. Seeing the smiles on our students' faces each day reminds me why I love coming to work. What truly sets our school apart is our strong sense of community and our commitment to growing our faith, improving, and being the very best we can be for every child.
Lisa Herr
Bookkeeper
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because I love that the school inspires employees, families, and students to dedicate their lives to loving and serving Christ.
Jennifer Carbaugh
Director of Grant Writing
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because it gives me the creative freedom to tell powerful stories of our student growth, community need, and educational excellence.
Terry Smith
Admin Assistant
Employed: 1989
I love MSS because I love the children and watching them grow and mature with the love of Mother Seton herself! The families and their helpfulness, concern, kindness, and so much more! Mother Seton is a community that makes you feel good and blessed to be a part of! If you are in need of help or even an ear to listen and talk to, you know that someone will always be there for you. Not only do all the above things happen inside MSS but also outside of MSS. If you pass someone in Walmart, Target, etc., they always say Hi! The LOVE is always flowing! God is always present!
Marybeth White
School Nurse
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because I love the heart of the teachers and staff and their connection with the students.
Pre-K 3 and 4
McKenzie Paull
Pre-K 3 Teacher
Employed: 2022
I love MSS because of the incredible community. I have formed deep, lasting bonds with my coworkers, and it is a privilege to be a part of our students' learning and growth.
Natalie Keller
Pre-K 4 Teacher
Employed: 2020
I love MSS because it gives me a sense of purpose, and at times I feel like it is my second home. I enjoy helping students grow, learn, and develop an excitement for learning. I also enjoy getting to know all the kind families each year.
Jessica Munson
Pre-K 4 Teacher, Before Care Teacher
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because it is a close-knit community that is always willing to help. From the first day I started at MSS, everyone was willing to help each other out in the school and outside of the school as well. Whether it's to give each other ideas or strategies to help in the classroom, or events like the Walkathon that help raise money for people in need.
Tammy Harrington
Pre-K Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because I run into so many of the kids outside of school. It makes it easy to have connections with families as well as students. Also, all four of my children are MSS alumni!
Nicole Mayhew
Pre-K 4 Teacher Assistant
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because it's a tight-knit community.
Jadyn Baker
Pre-K 3 Teaching Assistant, Before/After School Care Assistant
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because I can always find the support and guidance I need for any given situation.
Primary K-2
Julia Cover
Kindergarten Teacher
Employed: 2016
I love MSS because of its rich history and deep connection to Elizabeth Ann Seton. Being part of a school founded on her faith and values is such a blessing, and I feel that it is an honor to carry on her legacy.
Dawn Kuti
K Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2021
I love MSS because of the generations of families that continue to be involved in the school and the teaching of the Catholic faith.
Katherine Bowers
Kindergarten Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because it feels like a family. In our community, everyone knows your name and greets you with a smile.
Sister Margaret Ann Wooden, D.C.
Gr 1 Teacher
Employed: 2016
I love MSS because of the nurturing, stimulating environment where I feel valued and inspired to help the students achieve their full potential.
Taylor McIlrath
Gr 1 Teacher
Employed: 2020
I love MSS because of the connections I am able to make with the staff and students.
Jessica Eiker
Gr 1 Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because of the kids! They bring so much joy to our school.
Renee Lawyer
Gr 1 Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2022
I love MSS because of the wonderful community. The faculty and staff are always there to help each other out, and it is such a pleasure to work with the students! I’m grateful to be apart of the community!
Melaney Mullineaux
Gr 2 Teacher
Employed: 2008
I love MSS because it is a place where everyone is welcome. It's a privilege to teach and to be a part of such a vibrant faith-based community.
Tammy Bidinger
Gr 2 Teacher
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because everyone is welcomed with open arms. Our strong Catholic values, supportive school family, and commitment to helping every child succeed make it a truly special place where meaningful relationships are built.
Kelly Sumner
Gr 2 Teaching Assistant, Co-Director, Before and After School Care
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because it's a community built around faith, family, learning, and service.
Mary Neibecker
Gr 2 Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2022
I love MSS because it is a special place to work. All the staff encourage each other, and the students quickly become like family. Thank you, Mother Seton!
Intermediate 3-4
Amy Baker
Gr 3 Teacher
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because it is a place where we all support and care for each other. MSS feels like a family.
Samantha Bowers
Grade 3 Teacher
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because we are a community that continuously supports, inspires, and lifts each other up.
Emily Sharp
Gr 4 Teacher
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because I can express my faith with my students and teach them about the love and miracles of God in tandem with academic subjects. I love the relationships that I have made with the families of MSS as well! It is a privilege to partner with families in their student's education.
Ann Warthen
Gr 4 Teacher
Employed: 2005
I love MSS because, in teaching there, I am awarded the unique opportunity each and every day to play a role in helping to continue and share with others the important and faith-filled legacy of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton.
Middle School 5-8
Kellie Marr
Gr 5 Teacher
Employed: 2015
I love MSS because of its strong foundation in faith, its connection to Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton, and its peaceful setting surrounded by history (Emmitsburg & Gettysburg).
Alyssa Eichelberger
Gr 5 Teacher
Employed: 2026
I love MSS because it is more than just a place where I teach. It is a community that feels like family.
Sarah King
MS Math, 6A Homeroom
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because of the tight-knit community, all of the fun traditions, and the emphasis on faith and the call to uphold the mission of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton.
Regina Zabinski
MS ELA Teacher, 6B Homeroom
Employed: 2026
I love MSS because of its community, which has already been so welcoming to me. It's also very special to be part of a school that has such a profound connection to the history and legacy of Catholic education in the United States.
Chris Cosentino
MS Religion Teacher, 7A Homeroom
Employed: 2020
I love MSS because we are a family and everyone cares for the well-being of each other.
Enrichment
Teri Monacelli
Library/Media Coordinator
Employed: 1999
I love MSS because I love the kids, and I am always excited to come back to school each fall!
Cheryl Carney
Music Teacher
Employed: 1997
I love MSS because of the legacy and history that is this school. It always feels like Elizabeth Ann Seton is walking these halls and watching over the students, staff, and faculty.
Amber Reaver
PE Teacher
Employed: 2020
I love MSS because it's more than just the place where I teach. It's been home for my family, too. My children have attended MSS, so I've experienced this community as both a teacher and a parent. The faith, supportive environment, and genuine sense of family make it a special place to learn, grow, and belong.
Magon Ress
Art Teacher
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because, just like a work of art, each student, faculty, and staff member contributes their own unique colors, ideas, and talents. Together we create something truly special. I'm grateful to be part of a school community that inspires creativity and helps everyone succeed.
Melanie Ware
Spanish K-5, MS ELA Teacher
Employed: 95-07; 2026
I love MSS because it is a place where children can learn in a safe, nurturing environment while finding that they can make the world a better place.
Hanna Thomas
Spanish 6-8 Teacher
Employed: 2026
I love MSS because of the great staff and the incredible students. When you are here, you truly feel like you belong!
Brian Smolinski
Band Teacher
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because of how true the family atmosphere is among the staff, and it exudes into the environment of the school. With the nature of my position, I'm only at MSS once per week, yet I'm never treated like some stranger or outcast. I always enjoy catching up with everyone during each visit.
Learning Center
Lizbeth Bull
Learning Center Teacher
Employed: 2011
I love MSS because of its strong values and sense of community.
Laura Gannon
Learning Center Teacher
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because it feels like a second family to me. Everyone is helpful, kind and supportive of each other. We celebrate each other’s successes and look out for each other in times of need.
Emily Hanson
Learning Center Teacher
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because of its strong sense of community and faith. Everyone is so kind and supportive, which truly makes our school feel like a family.
Natalie Borkoski-Parker
Co-Director, Before and After School Care, Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because of the sense of community that the school creates with its faculty/staff, students, and families.
Sister Maggie Scally, D.C.
Student Support Coordinator
Employed: 1979-1983; 2020-Present
I love MSS because of the traditions that have former students come back to join us. I love that families have enrolled here for generations. I love that the faculty give themselves fully to the children as if they’re family. (And sometimes they are!)
Catherine Beach
Counseling Intern
Employed: 2026
I love MSS because it is an inclusive and encouraging environment where children are prioritized and respected.
Advancement
Jennifer Buchheister
Director of Advancement
Employed: 2009
I love MSS because there are generations of students who also love MSS.
Laurie Szukalski
Director of Enrollment
Employed: 2018
I love MSS because all four of my children graduated from here, and I saw firsthand how its faith-based curriculum gave them a strong moral compass and prepared them for high school and beyond. Now, as an employee, I can also say from experience that Mother Seton is a truly wonderful place to work.
Lynn Tayler
Director, Marketing and Communications
Employed: 2013
I love MSS because it's faith-filled, welcoming, and service-oriented. My children are successful, professionally and personally, because of the values they've learned and the academic excellence they were inspired to strive for.
Nell Trainor
Advancement Assistant, Student Support and Accountability Coordinator
Employed: 2021
I love MSS because of the kind, creative, and curious students, the supportive and collaborative staff, and the loyal, dedicated community that makes the school so welcoming.
Cafeteria
Susan Reaver
Cafeteria Manager
Employed: 2019
I love MSS because it is special to me and my family because my husband , children and now grandchildren go here it means a lot to me to be part of a school with such a strong tradition of Faith learning and community.
Joelle Miller
Cafeteria Assistant
Employed: 2021
I love MSS because of its uplifting values and the strong sense of community among its staff and families. It's a place where kindness, support, and encouragement are part of everyday life.
Amber Breeden
Cafeteria Assistant
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because they care for each individual student and their needs big or small.
Melissa Legg
Cafeteria Assistant
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because I love being involved in my daughter’s school and community. Working here keeps me even more connected!
Bonnie Coblentz
Cafeteria Assistant
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because co-workers, teachers, children, and all staff greet you with a smile. The children are always thanking us for their lunches. It's a wonderful place to work.
Michele Kiser
Cafeteria Assistant
Employed: 2021
I love MSS because of its uplifting values and the strong sense of community among its staff and families. It's a place where kindness, support, and encouragement are part of everyday life.
Before and After Care
Natalie Borkoski-Parker
Co-Director, Before and After School Care, Teaching Assistant
Employed: 2024
I love MSS because of the sense of community that the school creates with its faculty/staff, students, and families.
Kelly Sumner
Gr 2 Teaching Assistant, Co-Director, Before and After School Care
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because it's a community built around faith, family, learning, and service.
Jadyn Baker
Pre-K 3 Teaching Assistant, Before/After School Care Assistant
Employed: 2023
I love MSS because I can always find the support and guidance I need for any given situation.
Camille Shoemaker
After School Care Assistant
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because of the wonderful sense of community and the joy of seeing our students each day.
Josie Kaas
Before & After Care Assistant
Employed: 2026
I love MSS because I love being part of such a caring community and making afternoons fun and memorable for the students.
Facilities
Kevin Riffle
Lead Facility Maintenance
Employed: 2022
I love MSS because the students and staff are awesome.
Transportation
Linda Buffa
Bus Driver
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because I have never felt more comfortable and appreciated!
Brittany Neal
Bus Driver
Employed: 2025
I love MSS because not only is everyone so welcoming, but I love starting and ending my day seeing the students' smiling faces. And an added bonus, my daughters are getting a wonderful education with values and real life skills. I love that they are able to experience fun days and being traditional kids-which makes school fun.
